God Doesn’t Play Dice. But What About Poker?
October 10, 2010 Leave a comment
Albert Einstein hated… hated… hated quantum mechanics because he said he didn’t believe that God plays dice.
Which brings up the obvious question: what does Einstein have against dice? It’s a perfectly fun game. Did he get ripped off in a back alley craps game? Did he just have bad luck, or dislike cubed objects? The questions are tantalizing.
Anyways, maybe God doesn’t play dice. I think he may use decoherence in a eternal probabilistic game of poker.
Perhaps it’s one way to shuffle the deck and divvy out the next hand? It’s a far more apt description than shaking up the dice. Poker, after all, requires an interaction with the cards to determine a hand. You can bluff. And seek new combinations. Pass and wait for a better hand. There’s some strategy, after all. Dice is more–what you see is what you get.
That would be a far more satisfying–to me, at least–compromise in the determinism and indeterminism debate. In a perfectly deterministic universe, there would be no surprise at all. And how fun would that be? A totally indeterministic universe would be chaotic. I like to call it Parking Lot Physics. Have you ever been in a WalMart parking lot during the holidays. Where is your God there?
But there seems to be evidence for a third way–a mixture of surprise and skill–that drives our universe.
We have a mixture of entanglement and decoherence. Of superposition and shuffling. Of order and entropy.
But whose shuffling the deck? Whose shaking the dice?
That’s for another day.